Unconditional Parenting by Alfie Kohn
I have had every intention of writing about my new Gospel of Child Rearing but it hasn’t happened and I think I know why.
- I’m not a writer
- Anything I write that may be wise, clever, or funny is wholly accidental
- I could never do the book justice
- Just go read the book for yourself
This book is amazing. It will contradict everything you ever thought you knew about raising children. In the past three days my patience has doubled (wait a minute that might not be saying much) and I find my self reasoning (or trying to!) with my children instead of ordering them about. Coincidentally I also stopped eating sugar, again, three days ago. Yet…the book. It’s insightful. It’s enlightening. It’s…just read it already. In fact, read all of his books. I am. .
I’ll leave you with my favorite idea from the book. “…if they do something we don’t like, we’ll make them suffer in order to change their behavior. The only remaining question is how we’ll make them suffer: by causing physical pain through hitting or by causing emotional pain through enforced isolation. And both are based on getting kids to focus on the consequences of their action to themselves, which is, of course, very different from raising children to think about how their actions will effect other people.”
“When we punish, in other words, we lead children to ask, “What do they (the grown-ups with the power) want me to do, and what will happen to me if I don’t do it?” Notice that this is a mirror image of the question evoked in a home or classroom in which children are promised a reward for being good: “What do they want me to do, and what will I get for doing it?” Both questions are entirely about self-interest. And both are completely different from what we’d like kids to ask themselves – for example, “What kind of person do I want to be?”
What kind of person do you want your child to be?
Labels: Book Reviews, Sweet Little Troublemakers








4 Comments:
I will have to check this out. I am a Love and Logic parent myself, but I am always up to learning new things.
I love L&L so much because it teaches my girls to make good decisions now so that they can have an easier time making them later. I just read the synopsis of the book. Sounds a lot like L&L. I am going to read it!
This is a very good book. I am reading it now. I started to realize that my time-out efforts with my child were failing to help her. It usually ended with her saying "I'm sorry I didn't mean to hurt you" to the baby regardless of why she was actually on time out. I am very glad that I found this book. It has helped me to realize a lot about parenting that other books or authors only touched on. Now I have found a better way that will give me peace.
Ooh, I am so happy to see this here. I just found you via Kerflop. I'm interested in TJed and saw that you were a speaker at the forum she attended. She linked to another speaker who seems to have a VERY different parenting style than I am comfortable with, and, not yet having read the TJed book, I got concerned that it may not mesh with my non-behavioristic views of children and parenting.
Does TJed mention much about parenting style, rewards and punishments, etc? I'm assuming if there's room for such different styles as the "you didn't do what I said, here's your punishment, accept it happily and now go back and do what I said" model and the model espoused in Unconditional Parenting, it must not say much about it at all.
Cathryn,
TJEd doesn't promote any type of parenting style other than developing a great relationship with your children. We all have to find the best way to do that.
The DeMills have a new book out now that you might be interested in reading after you read the first one. TJEd talks about why and I have heard this next one goes more into how. I haven't read it yet as it is brand new.
Post a Comment
<< Home